Mavis Discount TireCole Muffler Your Account

Shopping Cart
Home  |  Tire Brands  |  Tire Reviews  |  Tire Deals  |  Reservation Center  |  About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Careers
Store Locator 

SHOP for TIRES →

Tire Reviews - Pirelli P4 Four Season



Consumer Tire Performance Ratings
based on 29 customer reviews
Overall Rating8.4 Hydroplaning Resistance8.5
Buy Again86% Cornering Stability8.5
Dry Traction8.8 Steering Responsiveness8.6
Wet Traction8.5 Ride Comfort8.7
Light Snow Traction8.3 Noise Level8.4
Deep Snow Traction7.8 Treadwear8.2
Ice Traction7.5 Miles Reported51,339
     8-10 = excellent        6-7 = good        4-5 = fair        1-3 = poor
guide to ratings

Mavis Discount Tire has received 29 tire reviews for the Pirelli P4 Four Season. This tire has received a 4 out of 5 Star rating with 86% of the respondents saying they would buy again. Dry Traction and Ride Comfort received the highest marks and total mileage that as been reviewed is 51,339.
Browse a list of all Pirelli tires

Customer Reviews: Pirelli P4 Four Season
Submitted on
Rating: Good
Buy Again: Probably
Tire size: 205/65TR16
Vehicle: 2012 Hyundai Sonata
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Wappingers Falls, NY
Overall Rating7.9 Hydroplaning Resistance7.0
Buy Again75% Cornering Stability8.0
Dry Traction8.0 Steering Responsiveness8.0
Wet Traction7.0 Ride Comfort8.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level10.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear
Ice Traction Miles Reported500

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: 225/60R16
Vehicle: 1999 Ford Crown Victoria
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Bellmore, NY
Overall Rating8.7 Hydroplaning Resistance8.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability9.0
Dry Traction9.0 Steering Responsiveness9.0
Wet Traction9.0 Ride Comfort8.0
Light Snow Traction9.0 Noise Level8.0
Deep Snow Traction8.0 Treadwear9.0
Ice Traction8.0 Miles Reported750
Very happy with these tires. With all the types of snow, ie; light, heavy, slushy, and sometimes combined with ice, these tires have performed very well, traction, cornering, starting and stopping. Sal and the mechnics at his shop are very good at what they do.

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: 215/65R16
Vehicle: 2012 Volvo XC70
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Easy Going
Location: West Stockbridge, MA
Overall Rating9.1 Hydroplaning Resistance9.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability9.0
Dry Traction9.0 Steering Responsiveness10.0
Wet Traction9.0 Ride Comfort10.0
Light Snow Traction9.0 Noise Level8.0
Deep Snow Traction8.0 Treadwear9.0
Ice Traction9.0 Miles Reported3,000
Smooth, quiet ride and good handling in rain, snow and ice.

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: P185/65R14
Vehicle: 1999 Mazda Protege
Driving Condition: Mostly Highway
Driving Style: Easy Going
Location: New Rochelle, NY
Overall Rating9.6 Hydroplaning Resistance
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability10.0
Dry Traction10.0 Steering Responsiveness10.0
Wet Traction9.0 Ride Comfort9.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level9.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear10.0
Ice Traction Miles Reported221
Really great tires installed by a really great staff at Mavis New Rochelle, NY...Many Thanks...!

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Probably
Tire size: 215/65R16
Vehicle: 2006 Chrysler Town & Country
Driving Condition: Mostly City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Sheffield, MA
Overall Rating8.3 Hydroplaning Resistance8.0
Buy Again75% Cornering Stability8.0
Dry Traction10.0 Steering Responsiveness8.0
Wet Traction9.0 Ride Comfort8.0
Light Snow Traction8.0 Noise Level9.0
Deep Snow Traction8.0 Treadwear8.0
Ice Traction8.0 Miles Reported350
They did a great job. Thank you

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: 215/65R16
Vehicle: 2005 Honda CR-V
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Poughquag, NY
Overall Rating9.4 Hydroplaning Resistance9.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability9.0
Dry Traction9.0 Steering Responsiveness9.0
Wet Traction9.0 Ride Comfort10.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level10.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear
Ice Traction Miles Reported1,500
I am not a "car guy", but these are excellent tires! They are quieter, smoother, more responsive and better handling than any tire ever put on my CR-V, including the factory originals! It's as if I installed new shocks! Ride very noticeably smoother and quieter. Great in the rain, as well. Buy these tires!

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Possibly
Tire size: 215/65R16
Vehicle: 2010 Kia Sportage
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Rome, NY
Overall Rating8.0 Hydroplaning Resistance
Buy Again50% Cornering Stability
Dry Traction8.0 Steering Responsiveness8.0
Wet Traction8.0 Ride Comfort9.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level10.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear8.0
Ice Traction Miles Reported1,000
Too soon to give a real glowing review, but tires feel real nice. Have to see when winter arrives.

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: P185/65R15
Vehicle: 2003 Toyota Corolla
Driving Condition: Mostly City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Thiells, NY
Overall Rating8.5 Hydroplaning Resistance7.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability8.0
Dry Traction9.0 Steering Responsiveness9.0
Wet Traction9.0 Ride Comfort9.0
Light Snow Traction8.0 Noise Level9.0
Deep Snow Traction8.0 Treadwear9.0
Ice Traction7.0 Miles Reported160
Great tires!

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: 195/60R15
Vehicle: 1995 Mercedes-Benz E320
Driving Condition: Mostly City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Brooklyn, NY
Overall Rating8.1 Hydroplaning Resistance7.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability7.0
Dry Traction8.0 Steering Responsiveness8.0
Wet Traction7.0 Ride Comfort9.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level9.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear
Ice Traction Miles Reported1,200
These tires addressed an issue with road noise for me. Since I drive a wagon, there is more road noise from the rear wheels. These P4's quieted the ride down very well and have provided competent, reliable service on pot-holed streets and on highways. Very satisfied, overall. No chance to review in wintry conditions yet, but I'll probably go to snow tires.

Submitted on
Rating: Good
Buy Again: Probably
Tire size: 175/65R14
Vehicle: 2002 Chevrolet Prizm
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Frankfort, NY
Overall Rating7.9 Hydroplaning Resistance9.0
Buy Again75% Cornering Stability8.0
Dry Traction8.0 Steering Responsiveness8.0
Wet Traction8.0 Ride Comfort8.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level7.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear8.0
Ice Traction Miles Reported500
Haven't had these tires for too long, but so far, Spring/Summer driving has been a pleasure w/ them. I own a set of snows, but am tempted to try these instead this coming Winter. As far as I can see--when it comes to tires, you really do "get what you pay for".

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: P185/65R15
Vehicle: 2002 Honda Civic
Driving Condition: All Highway
Driving Style: Easy Going
Location: Smithtown, NY
Overall Rating8.2 Hydroplaning Resistance8.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability8.0
Dry Traction8.0 Steering Responsiveness8.0
Wet Traction8.0 Ride Comfort8.0
Light Snow Traction8.0 Noise Level8.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear8.0
Ice Traction8.0 Miles Reported1,500
Excellent tires. I bought 4. Smooth ride and everybody at Mavis was very helpful.

Submitted on
Rating: Good
Buy Again: Probably
Tire size: 235/65R16
Vehicle: 2008 Honda Odyssey
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Honeoye Falls, NY
Overall Rating7.8 Hydroplaning Resistance
Buy Again75% Cornering Stability8.0
Dry Traction8.0 Steering Responsiveness8.0
Wet Traction8.0 Ride Comfort8.0
Light Snow Traction8.0 Noise Level7.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear
Ice Traction Miles Reported2,000
These tires are so good they scared away winter this year :).

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: P205/70TR15
Vehicle: 2004 Honda CR-V
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Overall Rating10.0 Hydroplaning Resistance10.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability10.0
Dry Traction10.0 Steering Responsiveness10.0
Wet Traction10.0 Ride Comfort10.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level10.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear
Ice Traction Miles Reported4
These tires are great. Great response, smooth ride in both dry and wet conditions. Definitely give you a feeling of control over your vehicle and trust/confidence in the tires' response to turning/cornering and braking. So far these tires have exceeded my expectations.Looking forward to seeing how they handle in next winter's snow and ice. I anticipate that I will not be disappointed. Can't speak about treadwear yet, too soon to tell...they still look like new!

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: P205/70TR15
Vehicle: 2004 Honda CR-V
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Overall Rating10.0 Hydroplaning Resistance10.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability10.0
Dry Traction10.0 Steering Responsiveness10.0
Wet Traction10.0 Ride Comfort10.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level10.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear
Ice Traction Miles Reported4
These tires are great. Great response, smooth ride in both dry and wet conditions. Definitely give you a feeling of control over your vehicle and trust/confidence in the tires' response to turning/cornering and braking. So far these tires have exceeded my expectations.Looking forward to seeing how they handle in next winter's snow and ice. I anticipate that I will not be disappointed. Can't speak about treadwear yet, too soon to tell...they still look like new!

Submitted on
Rating: Good
Buy Again: Probably
Tire size: P185/65R14
Vehicle: 1997 Honda Civic
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Nanuet, NY
Overall Rating7.0 Hydroplaning Resistance7.0
Buy Again75% Cornering Stability7.0
Dry Traction7.0 Steering Responsiveness
Wet Traction7.0 Ride Comfort7.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level7.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear
Ice Traction Miles Reported2,000
2000 miles is too soon to tell. The survey should be done closer to 10,000 after 1 year to truly know.

Submitted on
Rating: Excellent
Buy Again: Definitely
Tire size: P205/55TR16
Vehicle: 2000 Volkswagen Beetle
Driving Condition: Mostly Highway
Driving Style: Average
Location: Glenwood Landing, NY
Overall Rating9.5 Hydroplaning Resistance10.0
Buy Again100% Cornering Stability10.0
Dry Traction10.0 Steering Responsiveness9.0
Wet Traction10.0 Ride Comfort10.0
Light Snow Traction9.0 Noise Level9.0
Deep Snow Traction9.0 Treadwear9.0
Ice Traction9.0 Miles Reported1,000
too early to rate treadwear

Submitted on
Rating: Good
Buy Again: Probably
Tire size: P205/55TR16
Vehicle: 1998 Volvo S90
Driving Condition: Combined Highway/City
Driving Style: Average
Location: Burnt Hills, NY
Overall Rating7.6 Hydroplaning Resistance
Buy Again75% Cornering Stability8.0
Dry Traction8.0 Steering Responsiveness7.0
Wet Traction8.0 Ride Comfort8.0
Light Snow Traction Noise Level8.0
Deep Snow Traction Treadwear7.0
Ice Traction Miles Reported5,000
Great tire for a great price.


We Will Beat Any Tire Price

Tire Promotions

Buy 3 Tires Get 1 FREE

Brake Special Coupon